Mariah Carey performed her final Christmas Time tour concert at the Barclays Center in Brooklyn on Tuesday, Dec. 17 after canceling three prior shows due to the flu. Rihanna happened to be in the crowd and got her breast signed by Carey.

Billboard looked at every Christmas track released in the past 25 years, “ranked by total consumption (streams and sales),” and found the most popular to be “Santa Tell Me” by Ariana Grande, from 2014. It’s hard to say whether the track would be more or less canonical if Grande’s label agreed to her original diea for the music video.